Read Time:4 Minute, 51 Second

Finding the best one for your business can be overwhelming if you’re in the market for a new payroll provider. This guide will help you learn about the different types of services and how to select one that is right for your company.

Table of Contents

Budget is an important consideration, and it’s worth researching pricing models to ensure you get the best deal possible. Also, make sure the service stays compliant with regulatory requirements.

Cost

When evaluating your options, consider the features you need. At a minimum, you will want to ﬁnd a service that offers payroll processing, direct deposit, year-end tax services, and a dashboard or portal that allows employees and administrators to access their data. Additional needs may include time tracking for hourly and salaried employees, workers’ compensation administration, garnishment payments, or business insurance tracking.

Your budget will also factor into your decision. Determine a reasonable payroll service budget and compare providers to see which offers the most value within that price range. It would help if you also looked at add-on fees, which can be costly and vary by provider.

Lastly, make sure to evaluate customer reviews. You can often ﬁnd unbiased online payroll reviews from real business owners on third-party sites. Using this resource can help you identify common themes and pitfalls and provide valuable insights into the user experience. Depending on your requirements, you may also want to search for videos that walk you through the software to understand its functionality. This can be especially helpful if you have questions or run into glitches when you ﬁrst begin using the system.

Features

Choosing a payroll service provider is more than just selecting a program that automates some of your tasks. You want to choose one that ﬁts your company’s needs and goals, including compliance and eﬃciency.

First, deﬁne your business’s requirements. What functions do you need from a PSP, and what do you anticipate as your business grows? This will help you narrow down potential providers.

Look for a company that offers ﬂexible plans to accommodate your business’s growth. If you need to add employees, expand into new markets, or change payroll frequencies, a PSP should be able to adapt to your changes.

Another critical feature is robust and easy-to-access payroll reports. Access to this information is vital for making essential business decisions and maintaining compliance. It would help to consider whether the software can break down these reports by employee or department to provide a more granular look at your payroll data. Also, ensure the software can generate year-end W-2 or 1099 forms for your employees, if applicable. This will save you time and ensure your business complies with federal and state tax laws.

Security

As the payroll process involves handling sensitive data, security is an essential factor. Look for a provider that takes data security seriously, with measures like encryption and secure servers in place. Ask potential providers about their experience with data breaches and what protections they offer if a breach does occur.

Another area to consider is compliance management. If your business must comply with speciﬁc regulations, like minimum wage and overtime laws, it’s essential that a PSP can handle those details quickly and accurately. Look for a provider that updates its systems with new rules as they take effect and provides penalty protection in case of errors.

Look for a provider that can handle all of the responsibilities associated with payroll processing, including deductions, tax ﬁlings, garnishment payments, PTO management, and workers’ compensation administration. A good PSP should also be able to generate year-end tax forms, like W-2s and 1099s, for employees. These documents report anemployee’s annual wages and tax withholding amounts, which are necessary for employees to ﬁle their taxes. Ask your potential providers if they provide these services and if they charge any additional fees for them.

Integrations

A robust payroll integration can help you complete tasks faster and keep your records consistent. Look for a provider with various integrations that work with your tools. For example, it offers a directory of third- party business management tools that can be integrated with its payroll software. You can click the device you want to connect to, and then you will be redirected to that company’s website to log in and complete the setup.

Managing employee information and payroll processes can be complicated, especially for organizations with multiple locations. Seamless integrations between human resource information systems (HRIS) and payroll platforms can make it easier to ensure that changes to employee details, salary increases, and tax withholdings are accurately reﬂected in paychecks.

Choosing a provider that can integrate with your current systems will simplify switching to a new one.

Look for a provider that has a user-friendly dashboard or portal so that employees and managers can access their data without prior training. This is essential for the onboarding process and ongoing system maintenance.

Customer Support

As a business owner, bookkeeper, accountant, or human resources (HR) professional, you know payroll is critical to your company’s success. However, doing payroll internally can be time-consuming and prone to errors. With the right payroll service provider (PSP), you can save time and reduce the likelihood of costly mistakes.

When evaluating potential providers, ask how they support their clients with day-to-day questions and requests. Look for a PSP with dedicated trainers and account managers who can handle your needs.

Additionally, determine whether their customer service representatives are available via phone, email, and live chat.

Some payroll companies may also offer support centers that host a variety of resources like FAQs and curated articles. In addition, look for a provider that stays updated on the latest changes in compliance laws. This way, they can help you avoid ﬁnes and penalties in case of a mistake.